Do you all pay much attention to art or the art world? I am not an art devotee however I have enjoyed my occasional trip to a museum or gallery. I cannot for example, describe how the Dutch painter Rembrandt borrowed from the Italian painter Caravaggio, but in a multi-choice test where I am to circle the names of painters, I probably would have gotten the answer correct.
I also sometimes read articles about art; hopefully improve myself. One article a few years ago in particular caught my eye. This article discussed “The Holy Virgin Mary,” a modern piece of art work by a Chris Ofili. In the words of one observer, the work is “a big semi-abstract collage eight feet high and six feet wide, resting on two balls of resin-covered elephant dung with pins stuck into them spelling out the words Virgin and Mary. The Virgin, simply drawn, is black, in a flowing blue-gray robe, a flowerlike form, flat against a gold backdrop. There are small cutouts from adult magazines stuck to the picture to suggest putty.” This observer went on to say, “Like all of Ofili’s collages, the work is colorful and glowing.”
Maybe. But what was interesting for me about the article was not that it went into a discussion on the merits of modern art, or whether public money should support such artistic endeavors or how it may insult the Christian faith. Rather the article was discussing another issue: It’s one thing to preserve and protect a painting from Renoir or Monet from the ravages of time, air pollution, light and other influences that can degrade a work of art over the centuries. But how do you preserve an artwork that is made of organic material or less stable components --- like elephant dung?
That’s the problem facing art conservators. Stuff melts or rots. Rubber disintegrates. Dried mud flakes and blows away. Art Conservators who deal with this issue are facing the problem of “inherent vice.”
The phrase “inherent vice” originates from the marine insurance industry. It’s a legal term that means: a quality within an object, material or property that results in its tending to deteriorate or destroy itself: in short, a built-in tendency to self-destruct.
Put some apples in a barrel, and before long, they’ll rot. Inherent vice. Put oranges in a basket, and within weeks, they’re not fit to eat. Inherent vice. Throw some elephant dung on a canvas, and within months it will start to degrade. Inherent vice.
Inherent vice is one way for us to understand the subject of today’s gospel. When the external behavior stinks, it’s because the inner life is rotten. When the hand is doing wrong, the heart cannot be right. “Nothing outside a man can make him 'unclean' by going into him. Rather, it is what comes out of a man that makes him 'unclean.'” Jesus here — as he does elsewhere in the gospels, is refining what it means to be righteous. Righteousness is an attribute that a person's actions are justified and that a person has been "judged" or "reckoned" as leading a life that is pleasing to God.
The prevailing notion at the time of Jesus was that righteousness was about what we did. It was about actions. It was about behavior. Do this --- to the point of how to wash hands and live.
Jesus said “No.” Righteousness is about who we are. Righteousness is not what you do on the outside, but who you are on the inside. Righteousness is not about the hand, washed or unwashed, it is about the heart. The good news is that if we can get the heart right, everything else will fall into place.
That being so, we’ve got a big problem — the problem of inherent vice, the same problem faced by people then as now, because the heart has this built-in tendency to grow foul and rotten resulting in foul and rotten behaviors. Jesus gives us his top 12 later in this lesson: “For from within, out of men's hearts, come evil thoughts, sexual immorality, theft, murder, adultery, greed, malice, deceit, lewdness, envy, slander, arrogance and folly. All these evils come from inside and make a man 'unclean.'”
Of course, there’s hope. Before I explain why, just a reminder that inherent vice is excluded by most marine property insurance policies for good reason — rot, decay and deterioration are natural, normal and innate --- in other words --- expected. For example: say we are shipping apples from Washington state in the US to Nagoya, Japan and the ship is slowed by weather and some of the fruit rots, the insurance company is not liable.
On the other hand, if the destruction of the unspoiled apples is caused by an on-board fire, we would be covered. Yet, it would be trite to talk about salvation as an insurance policy against the inherent vice of the heart.
Rather we have to think more deeply. The religious leaders at the time of Jesus were not unintelligent. They understood “inherent vice.” So what drove all these people to the point of distraction, clean hands but not clean hearts? It is the power of fear.
Though the tradition of washing hands had begun for the Pharisees in all sincerity, by Jesus' time a certain fear had set in. The system of ritual and legal performance had grown so rigid that it had taken control of them. Everything these individuals did hinged on the concern that maybe they would be breaking a law, and if one part of the tradition were to be broken, than maybe the whole tradition would die out, and if the tradition died, then maybe the whole faith, hope and love would die out.
Fear does that to people. It turns minor concerns into obsessions. That same fear deludes us. We are afraid of our inherent vice. We are afraid that if something in our system fails, spoils, then we will fail --- “I am a failure.” If something in our system of belief is proven shaky, if something in our system of society changes, if something in our system of relationships or life suddenly is broken, then fear causes us to think that we are failures, we are broken. In short, fear distorts the truth.
Fear also tricked the people at the time of Jesus into thinking that if they did the proper external acts, then they would be made inwardly clean. For example, if they washed their hands before every meal, then nothing unclean would ever enter them. The inherent vice in their lives would not accelerate and dominate their lives. The same fear often drives us into an obsession with what goes into our lives. Thus, we try not to get dirty.
Or possibly, our deepest fear is that there really is uncleanness in us and we are afraid to face it. Our deepest fear may be that we really are guilty and despite whatever we do to be made clean --- wash our hands before eating or pray before going to bed at night --- despite anything we do, our fear is that there is no way to be made clean, no way to be made whole. That also is the fear that drove the religious leaders to practice and teach to such a degree, in all manner of life, that Jesus finally called them "whitewashed tombs," clean on the outside but dead on the inside.
It is to those deepest fears that Jesus speaks. There is a way out. It is the way of freedom because it is freedom that is the opposite of fear. It was the freedom of Jesus that troubled the Pharisees so. They found him to be blatantly disregarding the tradition of the elders. But it was also the freedom of Jesus that drew people to him. He was free not to be scared of society or of his enemies but to speak truth to them in love. It was the freedom of Jesus that enabled him to accept those who were different: the outcasts, the unclean.
It is that freedom that Jesus says allows us to look at ourselves honestly and to see that, yes, indeed, there is uncleanness, inherent vice, in all of us. There is all manner of sin. There is plenty to be ashamed of. But it is freedom, too, free will, which enables us to accept God’s grace, the mercy and forgiveness of God. It is freedom, finally, which enables all of us to love.
God does not exclude our inherent vice from the scope of his love for us. God’s love is a comprehensive package that covers the full range of human failings. With all-encompassing mercy, God says to us, “You are forgiven, no matter how rotten you are.” God can do so because Jesus Christ has got us covered.