Luke 2: 22-40
I find it very interesting that at this point, early in the life of Jesus, there is a famous duo. These two, Anna and Simeon, were not married and we do not get a sense that they even knew each other; nevertheless they are a double act that we dare not separate.
We tend to dissect their voices into separate categories, Simeon and then Anna, as if their songs were distinct classes, the voice of a devout follower and then the voice of a prophetess. Rather, Anna and Simeon are like Simon and Garfunkel, Ginger Rogers and Fred Astaire, Rodgers and Hammerstein, Sherlock and Watson, fish and chips. Luke, I believe, emphasizes that we should see them, the two together, working and complementing and thus, are be seen in tandem, because it is their combination, and the words they speak, that are central for us to understand.
The Holy Spirit directed that this duo would come together at a moment when this family with their newborn had fulfilled the purification customs of that culture and then moved on to having this first born male blessed. Just as we cannot separate the voices of a duo singing, without also destroying the integrity of the duet, God through the Holy Spirit is placing an exclamation point in both Simeon and Anna on this child. And, God is doing so in the most important place for observant Jews, the Temple. The words of these two elders also point to what was to happen in thirty or so years, “a light for revelation to the Gentiles and for glory to your people Israel.”
Why? Why is this duo speaking with one voice together? This pair is coming together to not only express incredible joy of this long expected newborn child, the promised anointed one, but something else, grief and … the cross.
If you have Bibles in front of you, you will notice that all that separates today’s lesson in Luke from the wonderful story of the shepherds running from the manger to tell all that they had seen and heard is one line on the fact that the newborn was circumcised and given the name Jesus. Then all of a sudden, it is Mary, Joseph and the baby who are traveling to Jerusalem and the Temple, no less where they encounter Simeon and Anna.
Frederick Buechner, Presbyterian minister and author, described the first part of the encounter this way: “Years before, [Simeon had] been told he wouldn't die till he'd seen the Messiah with his own two eyes, and time was running out. When the moment finally came, one look through his cataract lenses was all it took. He asked if it would be all right to hold the baby in his arms, and they told him to go ahead but be careful not to drop him. ‘Lord, now let thou thy servant depart in peace, according to thy word, for mine eyes have seen thy salvation,’ he said, the baby playing with the fringes of his beard. The parents were pleased as punch, so he blessed them too for good measure. Then something about the mother stopped him, and his expression changed. What he saw in her face was a long way off, but it was there so plainly he couldn't pretend. ‘[This child is destined for the falling and rising of many in Israel... and a] sword will pierce through your soul," he said. He would have rather bitten off his tongue than said it, but in that holy place he felt he had no choice. Then he handed her back the baby and departed in something less than the perfect peace he'd dreamed of all the long years of his waiting.1
This quick departure from Bethlehem to Jerusalem is a reminder that this child of Christmas, this babe of Bethlehem, a joy to the world, was also born into a world of tragedy and pain and evil. Within the first two chapters of his gospel, Luke places us squarely in that little town of Bethlehem and then within walking distance of a hill called Golgotha.
It is like Luke somehow knew how the world would become about the birth of Jesus. As we know, there is an unmistakable romanticism that has grown up around Christmas, where even places like in Japan are moved to use the symbols and songs and candles. Much of that romanticism for Christians however, centers on the child asleep in the hay, on the hope, the wonder, and the love connected with the birth of this child.
In that sense, these words of Simeon may startle us into an unwanted realism, joy but also pain. But what Simeon’s words do more than anything else is demonstrate with inescapable precision the intimate connection between the manger and the cross.
But it does not end on that note, for just as the words of Simeon trailed off leaving Mary and Joseph pondering their meaning, we hear Anna. “Coming up to them at that very moment, she gave thanks to God and spoke about the child to all who were looking forward to the redemption of Jerusalem.”2
The sword is not the last word. Anna somehow knew, possibly as a prophetess, the only prophetess in the New Testament, that neither the manger nor the cross contained the last word about Jesus. The word about Jesus was not his remarkable and joyful birth in Bethlehem; nor was that finishing words spoken at the cross of Golgotha. The ultimate word was one spoken by the angel at the empty tomb on Easter morning, the “fear not!” A word that is powerful enough to dispel all the grief and all the darkness. Indeed, we can work out from Luke that it was not a star that the magi followed, but the first, faint hints of the sunrise of Easter that shone down on that Bethlehem stable.
With resurrection eyes Simeon and Anna sing and see through the darkness to not only the manger and but also the cross.
It is Christmas, a time for us to gather in joy for the fulfillment once again of God’s promises of love. If we can see with resurrection eyes this event, first like Simeon and then like Anna, perhaps from such a vision we can pull together a measure of genuine joy ? a joy that has little to do with the romanticism surrounding Christmas and New Year’s, a joy that does not ask us to "pack up all our cares and woes," and push them aside or into the past. Rather, a joy that begs us to come just as we are, to the manger … and the cross, weighed down with every kind of pain and sorrow and emptiness we may feel... to come and celebrate the only kind of joy that can sustain us in a time such as this... the same joy of Simeon and Anna, whose eyes beheld the promise of God despite the darkness.
Simeon was sustained by such a vision to trust that one day he would see the messiah; Anna was sustained by such a vision to proclaim to all and confidence, “thanks to God” and to speak “about the child to all who were looking forward to the redemption of Jerusalem.”3
May we be sustained as this year draws to a close and new day begins. And the Word became flesh and dwelt among us... Immanuel, God with us. God with us at the manger…God with us at the cross. Even here, even now, God with us. Amen.
1 Frederick Buechner, Peculiar Treasures, New York; Harper and Row, 1979, pp. 156-157.
2 Vs. 38
3 Vs. 38